BGBilly GaviganDiscuss an engagement

Declarant rights · Project finance · South Carolina

Declarant rights as collateral: classify every right before relying on the lien.

“All declarant rights” sounds comprehensive. It is not a collateral analysis. A lender must separate land, declaration-created powers, contracts, entity interests and association authority—then use the legal and recording system that governs each item.

A master-planned community is financed through a web of assets and authority. The developer may own future phases, hold construction contracts, control an entity, reserve development easements and possess declaration-created powers. Those items may have economic value, but they do not become one kind of collateral merely because a loan document calls them “declarant rights.”

Working rule: identify the source instrument, current holder, affected land, transfer conditions and related duties for each claimed right. Only then decide how it can attach, be perfected, released, valued or enforced.

A simple financing example.

Harbor Field is a hypothetical South Carolina community. Its declaration reserves rights to add future land, approve builders, use sales offices, appoint association directors during a stated control period and collect a defined reimbursement. Harbor Field Development, LLC owns Phase Three. A related company builds homes. The association owns completed common property.

The lender’s proposed security agreement covers “all declarant rights.” That phrase leaves the central questions unanswered. Does the expansion right depend on title to identified land? Is the reimbursement an account or another payment right? Does a pledge of the developer’s membership interests reach company assets? Can a creditor exercise a board-appointment power merely because it has a lien? The reliable file answers those questions separately.

Start with five different asset buckets.

  1. Land and land-dependent rights. Future phases, easements, infrastructure tracts and some development rights require title, a mortgage analysis, legal descriptions and land-record review.
  2. Declaration-created reserved powers. Expansion, builder approval, sales uses, easements, amendment authority and board appointment exist only to the extent the governing instruments create and preserve them.
  3. Contracts and payment rights. Development agreements, builder contracts and reimbursement covenants require their own classification, defenses, consent and assignment review.
  4. Entity interests. A pledge of shares or membership interests is different from a lien on assets owned by the entity. Control of the entity and ownership of its property are not the same transaction.
  5. Association powers and assets. Association accounts, common property and statutory or declaration-assigned powers do not become declarant collateral simply because the declarant appoints directors.

South Carolina makes the source instrument central.

The South Carolina Homeowners Association Act defines a declarant to include a person who reserves or succeeds to a special declarant right—authority created under the declaration or bylaws in addition to regular declarant rights. The Act also addresses recording and enforceability of governing documents. It does not classify every reserved power as real property, personal property or transferable collateral.

That is why the declaration matters first. Extract each defined right, its holder, the property or phase it benefits, its duration, the transfer clause, acceptance and assumption requirements, ownership conditions, consent and notice provisions, and any recording requirement.

South Carolina’s Cullen v. McNeal and Highlands Property Owners Association v. Shumaker Land Investments reinforce the instrument-and-sequence method. Cullen involved an express successor mechanism and assignment. Highlands rejected a later attempted assignment after the original holder had conveyed the relevant property interests and the deeds lacked the express transfer the covenants required. Neither opinion creates a universal collateral category.

Article 9 begins only after classification.

South Carolina Code § 36-9-109 applies Article 9 to consensual security interests in personal property and fixtures. The same section generally excludes creation or transfer of an interest in or lien on real property, subject to listed interfaces for fixtures and mixed collateral. A lender should not treat a UCC financing statement as a substitute for a mortgage, recorded assignment or title analysis.

For personal-property collateral, § 36-9-203 generally requires value, debtor rights in the collateral or power to transfer them, and the prescribed evidence of a security agreement—usually an authenticated agreement that describes the collateral. A filing cannot create a right the debtor never held, revive an expired power or satisfy a declaration condition by itself.

The security-agreement description and financing-statement indication also serve different functions. Under § 36-9-108, “all the debtor’s assets” or “all the debtor’s personal property” does not reasonably identify collateral in the security agreement. Under § 36-9-504, those phrases may indicate collateral in a financing statement. The lender still needs an objectively determinable grant in the security agreement.

Use a right-by-right collateral schedule.

A workable schedule includes the source instrument and section, recording information, named holder, exact right, affected land and phase, duration, transfer conditions, related duties, attachment evidence, filing or recording office, continuation deadline, release mechanics and proposed enforcement path.

That level of detail is especially important when a right has both personal-property and real-property features. Coordinated mortgage, assignment, declaration notice and UCC documents may be prudent, but parallel recording does not cure an invalid transfer or settle classification. All documents should identify the same debtor, right, property and transaction.

Select the correct perfection system.

Article 9 generally requires filing to perfect personal-property security interests, subject to statutory exceptions. Under § 36-9-501, ordinary South Carolina UCC filings go to the Secretary of State, while fixture filings and specified real-property-related filings go to the local real-property recording office. Mortgages and instruments affecting land remain subject to South Carolina real-property law and the recording rules in § 30-7-10.

The South Carolina Supreme Court’s Epstein v. Coastal Timber Co. is not a declarant-rights case, but its method is useful. The court analyzed timber according to the particular transaction and the UCC’s specific description and filing rules while preserving the role of real-estate law. The same discipline applies here: classify first, then select the record system.

Calendar the collateral lifecycle.

A standard financing statement is generally effective for five years under § 36-9-515. Continuation timing, amendments, debtor-name changes, new debtors, added collateral and partial releases require active administration. The register should track each filing number, filing office, lapse date, continuation window and related mortgage or recorded assignment.

Project events create a second calendar: expansion deadlines, permit renewals, phase releases, turnover triggers, completion covenants, bond expirations and amendment dates. A lender can maintain a perfected lien in an asset that later expires or becomes unusable. Legal existence and economic value must be monitored separately.

A lien is not authority to govern.

Before default, lender covenants can require preservation of rights, consent to amendments, delivery of notices, timely continuations and limits on releases. Those are contractual protections. They do not automatically make the lender the declarant, an association director, the manager or a permit holder.

After default, Article 9 permits collection and commercially reasonable disposition of qualifying collateral under §§ 36-9-607, 36-9-610 and 36-9-611. But a buyer receives only the debtor’s transferable interest and may still need title, recorded acceptance, transferee qualification, public approvals or compliance with the declaration before exercise. South Carolina’s Delaney v. First Financial also confirms that statutory disposition and notice duties are substantive constraints.

Southeast statutes make the sequencing visible.

North Carolina’s Planned Community Act and Condominium Act expressly address special declarant rights in foreclosure and other involuntary transfers, including a recorded request and allocation of successor liabilities. Virginia’s Condominium Act likewise separates voluntary transfer, foreclosure succession and security-only control.

Those statutes do not control a South Carolina project. They illustrate why three events should not be collapsed: creating a lien, acquiring title through enforcement and qualifying to exercise a reserved power.

The lender’s five-gate review.

  1. Identify: name every holder, asset, source instrument, affected phase and related duty.
  2. Classify and attach: determine the governing legal system, debtor rights, authorization, description and transfer conditions.
  3. Perfect and record: use the correct debtor name, filing office, land record, legal description and declaration-related instrument.
  4. Maintain: calendar continuations, project deadlines, amendments, entity changes, releases, turnover and record custody.
  5. Value and enforce cautiously: update title, UCC, entity, permit, dispute and insolvency facts before relying on remedies.

The practical conclusion.

Declarant rights can carry significant project value, but the value comes from lawful existence, remaining duration, satisfied conditions, compatible land ownership, transferable authority and the ability to perform accompanying duties. “All declarant rights” is not enough to prove any of those elements.

The disciplined lender file is granular. It lets counsel say which right is real property, which is personal property, which depends on a contract or entity interest, which belongs to the association and which remains legally unresolved. That precision is the foundation for sound underwriting, documentation and enforcement planning.

Build the seven-record successor file →

Separate land title from declarant authority →

Use the developer and HOA document checklists →

This article is an educational adaptation of a review-ready chapter in the Gavigan Legacy Plan. It is not legal advice, a title opinion, a UCC opinion, tax or insolvency advice, an appraisal, an expert opinion or a conclusion about any specific community. Harbor Field is hypothetical. South Carolina counsel, current citator and session-law review, official title, entity and UCC records, governing instruments and authenticated project documents are required for legal conclusions.